Skip to content
Business

Why stock indices keep setting records while the headlines stay gloomy

This article explores why the US stock market continues to reach record highs despite widespread economic pessimism. It examines strong corporate earnings, declining consumer confidence, the dominance of AI and technology stocks, and weakening market breadth to explain why Wall Street's optimism doesn't necessarily reflect the financial reality experienced by ordinary households.

Umair FaridContributor
Published · 6 min read
Why stock indices keep setting records while the headlines stay gloomy

On November 4, the Dow Jones Industrial Average jumped 1,569 points to close at 53,356.12 — its best day since April 2025 and its biggest post-midterm gain since 1982. The S&P 500 closed at 7,688.62 the same day. A month earlier, on October 6, the S&P 500 had set its record close at 7,818.93, one of 28 record closes in 2026. Read the headlines from the same weeks and you would think a different market existed: a hot inflation print, a Federal Reserve expected to raise rates in December, consumer sentiment near historic lows, and warnings of an AI bubble. The contradiction is real, and it has a cause. Stock indices and the headlines are measuring two different economies — one of corporate profits, the other of household experience — and in 2026 the gap between them has rarely been wider.

Earnings are doing the heavy lifting

The profit side of the story is unusually strong. FactSet's November 6 update put blended third-quarter earnings growth for the S&P 500 at 31.4% year on year, with 88% of companies having reported. Eighty-four percent beat earnings expectations and 74% beat on revenue. Revenue itself grew 14.3%. If the 31.4% figure holds, it will be the third consecutive quarter of earnings growth above 25% and the eighth straight quarter of double-digit growth — and all eleven sectors reported higher profits.

That is the engine behind the records. Indices are, in the end, a weighted average of expected future profits, and when profits grow by a third, prices have room to rise even while the news feels grim. Analysts expect 28.4% earnings growth in the fourth quarter and 33.3% for the full year. The forward price-to-earnings ratio sits at 17.7, below its five-year average of 19.8 — the market, by that measure, is not pricing the growth as if it were permanent.

Households are living a different year

The sentiment side tells the opposite story. The University of Michigan's preliminary consumer sentiment index rose to 51.0 in November from 48.0 in October, but that is still 10% below its February reading, and 57% of respondents said high prices had eroded their living standards — the highest share since May, up from 46% in February. Year-ahead inflation expectations eased to 4.3% from 4.7%, but the level itself is the point: households are still braced for prices to keep rising.

The two datasets are not contradicting each other; they are describing different populations. The stock market is owned disproportionately by higher-income households, whose spending and portfolios have held up. The sentiment survey samples everyone, including the majority who own little or no stock. When the survey's director, Joanne Hsu, noted “growing anxiety over a possible AI bubble,” sentiment even fell 5% among respondents with the largest stock portfolios — the one group that owns what the indices measure. The gloom is not invented. It is just not the same gloom the index sees.

Concentration is doing more work than it looks

The records are also narrower than the headline suggests. FactSet's own analysis shows that Micron and Nvidia alone account for roughly nine percentage points of the index's third-quarter earnings growth: without those two companies, growth would be 20% instead of 31.4%. The Magnificent Seven's earnings grew 22.6% in the quarter. And a Kobeissi Letter analysis found that 42 AI-related stocks have driven 67% of the S&P 500's price return since the start of 2024.

That concentration is the market's open secret. Technology makes up nearly 40% of the capitalisation-weighted S&P 500, against about 16% of the equal-weight version. When the largest names rise faster than the rest, the index pulls ahead of the typical stock — and in 2026 it has done so by a wide margin.

Rates stopped being the story

The usual explanation for a gloomy market — dear money — has not applied this year either. October's consumer price data came in hot: headline prices rose 0.4% on the month against a 0.3% forecast, core prices rose 0.3% for a third straight month. A December rate rise is now fully priced in futures, with a small chance of a 50-point move, and the 10-year Treasury yield sits near 5%. In most years that combination would cap a rally. In 2026 it has not, because earnings growth of 31.4% swamps the cost of money in the market's arithmetic. A company whose profits grow by a third can afford dearer borrowing; a household whose pay does not keep up with 4.3% expected inflation cannot. The rate story and the earnings story point in opposite directions, and earnings have won every round so far.

What a record high does and does not prove

A record close is a level, not a verdict. The S&P 500's 28 record closes in 2026 cluster in the first three quarters; by November 11 the index had pulled back to 7,619.38, still 2.55% below its October 6 record, after a week that included a 2.68% fall and a sharp chip sell-off. Records also say nothing about who participated. They are set by the largest companies, and in a concentrated market the largest companies can set records while most stocks stand still. That is exactly what the breadth data shows, and it is why a record high can coexist with a gloomy mood without either side being wrong.

The breadth check

The honest test of a rally is how many stocks are in it, and by that test 2026 is weak. The equal-weight S&P 500 — which gives each of the 500 companies the same weight — has lagged the capitalisation-weighted index every year since 2023: by 12.5 points in 2023, 12.1 in 2024, 6.5 in 2025 and 3.0 so far in 2026. Through September 30, the cap-weighted index was up 12.1% for the year against 9.1% for the equal-weight version. Only 40.8% of the 476 largest US stocks beat the S&P 500 over the year to September 30, and the median stock returned 7.8% against 15.7% for the index. One Goldman Sachs analysis put market breadth at its weakest since the dotcom bubble.

That does not make the rally false — the average stock still rose 9.1% through September — but it does make it fragile. A rally carried by a few dozen names depends on those names staying healthy. September was the warning: the equal-weight index fell more than 4% in the month, its longest multi-week losing streak since 2022, while the headline index stayed near its highs. Breadth is the part of the market that most resembles the real economy, and it has been saying something quieter than the records all year.

What to watch next

Four dates will decide whether the two stories converge or split further. US producer prices land on Friday, November 13 — the last inflation print before the Federal Reserve's December 8–9 meeting, where a 25-point rise is fully priced. Nvidia reports third-quarter results on November 17, and the call will be the next test of the AI demand story after CoreWeave's earnings revived it on November 11. The minutes of the Fed's October meeting arrive on November 18. And the final November consumer sentiment reading lands on November 20; the preliminary survey was taken before the election and before the November 5 sell-off, so it will be the first reading that includes all three. If earnings hold and breadth starts to follow, the records and the mood may finally meet. If the big names stumble while the average stock keeps lagging, the headlines will have been right all along — just early.

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Written by
Umair Farid
Contributor

Umair Farid is the Founder & CEO of Market Radar, covering crypto, forex, stocks, gold and the macro forces behind them.

View all posts by Umair

More in Business

View all